Keep, loan or sell? Raise funds with Tonali or Livarmento?

We asked for your views on which players Newcastle should keep, loan, and sell this summer.

Here are some of your comments:

Ben: Loan for Sean Neave, give the lad some experience. Sell Joe Wilock and Nick Pope while there’s still a market value and keep as many as possible as I feel like depth is important. I’d look to bring in a full-back on loan as cover and a quality goalkeeper to take the number-one shirt.

Rob: Keep Lewis Miley, he wasn’t a starter at the end of last season but don’t sell him for FFP and have him end up another Elliot Anderson! Loan Alex Murphy and Sean Neave, they gain little sitting on the bench and clearly aren’t trusted to play significant minutes just yet. Sell Sandro Tonali – I hate to say it but we need to keep Tino Livramento and Lewis Hall so if they want money in before investing let’s do it in a position we have ready made replacements at.

Gordon: Keep Alex Murphy – we need more cover at left-back and centre-back and he should get more game time next season. Loan out – Sean Neave, he looks promising but will be well down the pecking order next season, especially if we bring another forward in. Sell Odysseas Vlachodimos – he was obviously a make-weight in the Elliot Anderson sale two years ago and has been on loan since. He’s allegedly worth £20m, so cash in on him to help pay for a keeper who’ll get a place in our squad.

Andrew: We’ve already got rid of most of our fringe players, but I’d keep Joe Willock. When we play fast counter-attacking football, he’s been superb. I’d loan out Park Seung-soo. He has major flair and skill, but he needs to be put in low pyramid teams to be made more physical and strong. I’d be tempted to sell Tino Livramento. He’s fast and runs with the ball well, but he hasn’t got the technical skill Trippier had. Sell him when he’s worth a lot of money and buy a couple of young Lewis Halls with the fee.

Michael: Sell – not that it will happen but Anthony Elanga. Cannot fault the effort but I just don’t think he’ll ever be our answer on the right wing. Poor control and poor dribbling makes it hard to beat his man for starters and gives possession back to the opposition. Fringes – Park Seung-soo and Antonio Cordero – get them involved given the hype and the weakness in those positions. Loan – perhaps Sean Neave. Get him a good loan in the Championship and score some goals.