Jurors, lawyers and social workers face 'resilience test' in inaccessible courts

Nairavoice | 4h ago 151 0 6 min read
Jurors, lawyers and social workers face 'resilience test' in inaccessible courts

<div class&equals;"wp-block-wptelegram-widget-join-channel aligncenter">&NewLine;&Tab;<a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;t&period;me&sol;nairavoice" class&equals;"components-button join-link is-large has-text has-icon" target&equals;"&lowbar;self" rel&equals;"noopener noreferrer">&NewLine;&Tab;&Tab;<svg width&equals;"19px" height&equals;"16px" viewBox&equals;"0 0 19 16" role&equals;"img" aria-hidden&equals;"true" focusable&equals;"false">&NewLine;&Tab;&Tab;&Tab;<g>&NewLine;&Tab;&Tab;&Tab;&Tab;<path d&equals;"M0&period;465&comma;6&period;638 L17&period;511&comma;0&period;073 C18&period;078&comma;-0&period;145 18&period;714&comma;0&period;137 18&period;932&comma;0&period;704 C19&period;009&comma;0&period;903 19&period;026&comma;1&period;121 18&period;981&comma;1&period;33 L16&period;042&comma;15&period;001 C15&period;896&comma;15&period;679 15&period;228&comma;16&period;111 14&period;549&comma;15&period;965 C14&period;375&comma;15&period;928 14&period;211&comma;15&period;854 14&period;068&comma;15&period;748 L8&period;223&comma;11&period;443 C7&period;874&comma;11&period;185 7&period;799&comma;10&period;694 8&period;057&comma;10&period;345 C8&period;082&comma;10&period;311 8&period;109&comma;10&period;279 8&period;139&comma;10&period;249 L14&period;191&comma;4&period;322 C14&period;315&comma;4&period;201 14&period;317&comma;4&period;002 14&period;195&comma;3&period;878 C14&period;091&comma;3&period;771 13&period;926&comma;3&period;753 13&period;8&comma;3&period;834 L5&period;602&comma;9&period;138 C5&period;112&comma;9&period;456 4&period;502&comma;9&period;528 3&period;952&comma;9&period;333 L0&period;486&comma;8&period;112 C0&period;077&comma;7&period;967 -0&period;138&comma;7&period;519 0&period;007&comma;7&period;11 C0&period;083&comma;6&period;893 0&period;25&comma;6&period;721 0&period;465&comma;6&period;638 Z" ><&sol;path>&NewLine;&Tab;&Tab;&Tab;<&sol;g>&NewLine;&Tab;&Tab;<&sol;svg>&NewLine;&Tab;&Tab;Join Nairavoice On Telegram&Tab;<&sol;a>&NewLine;<&sol;div>&NewLine;<figure><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;static&period;files&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;bbcdotcom&sol;web&sol;20260609-143108-fe43574f32-web-3&period;9&period;0-5&sol;grey-placeholder&period;png" &sol;><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;ichef&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;news&sol;480&sol;cpsprodpb&sol;2094&sol;live&sol;93cf0940-6672-11f1-bfb6-f5752cbbcf38&period;png&period;webp" &sol;>Vikki Walton-Cole<&sol;figure>&NewLine;<p>By the time disabled social worker Vikki Walton-Cole arrived at court&comma; she was already &&num;8220&semi;in pain and unable to walk&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>She was not then a full-time wheelchair user&period; But as the court had no on-site or nearby parking&comma; it was a &&num;8220&semi;massive effort&&num;8221&semi; to walk from much further disabled parking&comma; she told BBC podcast Access All&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>When she then discovered the courtroom was only accessible by stairs&comma; she &&num;8220&semi;burst into tears&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&&num;8220&semi;That&&num;8217&semi;s obviously not a great way to arrive at court as the professional&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Walton-Cole says access issues like these were a &&num;8220&semi;massive factor&&num;8221&semi; in her decision to leave social work &&num;8220&semi;because there&&num;8217&semi;s just too many barriers in the court system&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The BBC has heard that inaccessible courts have led to a number of issues for disabled people&comma; including jurors feeling vulnerable&comma; and lawyers having to join cases remotely despite being metres from the courtroom&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Under the Equality Act&comma; courts must provide &&num;8220&semi;reasonable adjustments&&num;8221&semi; to those with disabilities&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>A HM Courts and Tribunals Service &lpar;HMCTS&rpar; spokesperson said&colon; &&num;8220&semi;We are working closely with disability groups to reduce the barriers disabled people face when accessing justice&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><b><i>Have you been affected by the issues raised in this story&quest; Contact Kateryna at&colon; accessall&commat;bbc&period;co&period;uk<&sol;i><&sol;b><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>After leaving social work&comma; Walton-Cole experienced another side of court when she was called for jury service last year at Guildford Crown Court in Surrey&period; She was keen to participate&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Then a full-time powerchair &lpar;electric wheelchair&rpar; user&comma; she spent weeks asking &&num;8220&semi;basic access questions&&num;8221&semi;&comma; but says she eventually gave up after finding the experience &&num;8220&semi;so stressful&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The court said they felt they did everything they could to meet her access needs&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Walton-Cole was repeatedly told she could be excused from jury service&comma; but pushed against that&comma; saying&colon; &&num;8220&semi;As a jury&comma; we&&num;8217&semi;re supposed to reflect society&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Victoria Gerrard is another wheelchair user who recently received a jury summons&period; She served as a juror earlier this year in Paisley Sheriff Court in Scotland&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>She said there was no accessible toilet in the jury area&comma; and &&num;8220&semi;there wasn&&num;8217&semi;t anyone practically saying&comma; &&num;8216&semi;If you need to use the bathroom&comma; here&&num;8217&semi;s how to manage it&period;&&num;8217&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&&num;8220&semi;It doesn&&num;8217&semi;t seem like it had been particularly thought of&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Gerrard could not use the stair-only juror exit&comma; and had to be escorted through public areas&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>This meant she regularly passed the accused and their family&comma; who &&num;8220&semi;glared&&num;8221&semi; at jurors and had to be removed by police after an &&num;8220&semi;outburst&&num;8221&semi;&comma; leaving Gerrard feeling especially vulnerable&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>On the final day of the trial&comma; all other jurors left together and arranged onward travel in groups&period; Gerrard said she was &&num;8220&semi;left sitting out the front of the building&comma; feeling very exposed&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&&num;8220&semi;No one even came to the door with me&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<figure><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;static&period;files&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;bbcdotcom&sol;web&sol;20260609-143108-fe43574f32-web-3&period;9&period;0-5&sol;grey-placeholder&period;png" &sol;><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;ichef&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;news&sol;480&sol;cpsprodpb&sol;b234&sol;live&sol;15609780-6673-11f1-bfb6-f5752cbbcf38&period;png&period;webp" &sol;>Victoria Gerrard<&sol;figure>&NewLine;<p>Barrister Holly Girven&comma; who is also a wheelchair user&comma; has praised court staff for being &&num;8220&semi;absolutely excellent&comma;&&num;8221&semi; but says she too has faced several access challenges&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>She said one court initially refused her access to the upstairs floors of a court in case there was a fire&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Girven described the accessible entrance to Edmonton County Court in London as a steep temporary ramp which she had to be pushed up by security and felt &&num;8220&semi;so unsafe&&num;8221&semi; using&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&&num;8220&semi;I don&&num;8217&semi;t think putting essentially a wooden temporary ramp over a few steps you can really say that &&num;8216&semi;we are truly accessible&comma;'&&num;8221&semi; she said&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<figure><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;static&period;files&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;bbcdotcom&sol;web&sol;20260609-143108-fe43574f32-web-3&period;9&period;0-5&sol;grey-placeholder&period;png" &sol;><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;ichef&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;news&sol;480&sol;cpsprodpb&sol;1642&sol;live&sol;76a9fcc0-6673-11f1-bfb6-f5752cbbcf38&period;png&period;webp" &sol;>Kateryna Pavlyuk<&sol;figure>&NewLine;<p>When a lift at Wandsworth County Court in London was out of service&comma; Girven had to join her hearing via Microsoft Teams from a separate conference room&comma; &&num;8220&semi;while everyone&comma; including my client&comma; went to the courtroom&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&&num;8220&semi;I must have been 10 metres from the courtroom&comma;&&num;8221&semi; she said&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&&num;8220&semi;You wouldn&&num;8217&semi;t expect a hospital to not be wheelchair-accessible&period; So I don&&num;8217&semi;t know why it&&num;8217&semi;s acceptable for some courts not to be&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Several wheelchair users interviewed by the BBC acknowledged the complexity and cost of upgrading old or listed court buildings&comma; but said one simple improvement would be for courts to provide better access information&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The BBC looked at the information provided by all courts in England and Wales and found varying levels of detail on accessibility&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>When we contacted courts to try and gather more detailed data on their accessible facilities&comma; we were told by the Ministry of Justice that this level of information was not centrally available&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Equality law barrister Gregory Burke&comma; a wheelchair user and the founder of AccessAble&comma; a website which produces detailed access guides&comma; said accessibility is also about information&comma; attitudes and dignity as well as the facilities themselves&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Burke said a coroner once told him that he was &&num;8220&semi;lucky&&num;8221&semi; they allowed him to address the court seated&comma; and he says a judge told him – in front of his client – &&num;8220&semi;not to wreck the place&&num;8221&semi; as he navigated the judge&&num;8217&semi;s chambers in a wheelchair&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>He stressed these incidents are notable exceptions&comma; and that &&num;8220&semi;overwhelmingly&comma; the judiciary have been very inclusive and accommodating&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>But he said disabled court users shouldn&&num;8217&semi;t be &&num;8220&semi;ambushed by inaccessibility&&num;8221&semi; and &&num;8220&semi;have to undergo a resilience test&&num;8221&semi; in going to court&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>He said this extra &&num;8220&semi;cognitive load&&num;8221&semi; can affect a lawyer or witness&&num;8217&semi;s ability to give their best evidence&comma; which could &&num;8220&semi;have a bearing on someone&&num;8217&semi;s liberty&comma; or the custody of a child&comma; or whether a business survives or not&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<figure><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;static&period;files&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;bbcdotcom&sol;web&sol;20260609-143108-fe43574f32-web-3&period;9&period;0-5&sol;grey-placeholder&period;png" &sol;><img src&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;ichef&period;bbci&period;co&period;uk&sol;news&sol;480&sol;cpsprodpb&sol;057f&sol;live&sol;6bb19ec0-6760-11f1-9146-c76696bad879&period;jpg&period;webp" &sol;>Gregory Burke<&sol;figure>&NewLine;<p>A report by the Magistrates&&num;8217&semi; Association found that inaccessibility &&num;8220&semi;severely damages morale and has led to resignations&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The issues highlighted in the report included a poorly positioned accessible toilet which &&num;8220&semi;risked a wheelchair user falling down a flight of stairs&&num;8221&semi;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The report concluded&colon; &&num;8220&semi;By failing to ensure all court buildings are accessible&comma; the court estate is undermining the efficient administration of justice&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>A HMCTS spokesperson said&colon; &&num;8220&semi;We understand that accessibility remains a challenge in some buildings&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&&num;8220&semi;We prioritise making sure courts are accessible to all users by listing cases at suitable venues and equipping our staff with mandatory training on reasonable adjustments to deliver a justice system that meets everyone&&num;8217&semi;s needs&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service said they have a webpage for jurors with information on accessibility&comma; and jury liaison officers who can assist disabled jurors&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>A spokesperson said&colon; &&num;8220&semi;We aim to make the courts as inviting and accessible as possible for everyone and welcome all feedback on how we can improve&period;&&num;8221&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;

Show Some Love By Sharing

Discover more from NAIRAVOICE.COM.NG

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Nairavoice
Nairavoice

Contributor at NairaVoice.com.ng

Related Posts

Leave a Reply