Garrett Mitchell’s career night powers Brewers to 4-2 win over Reds

Garrett Mitchell had just 10 starts against a left-handed pitcher all season long coming into the night. He had just a .547 OPS against lefties coming into the night, so it has been fairly understandable why. But Pat Murphy gave Mitchell the start on Wednesday night against Reds southpaw Andrew Abbott and he had a career night helping deliver the Crew a 4-2 victory.

Mitchell started the night with a single against Abbott in the first inning after the Brewers had already scored a pair of runs on an RBI groundout by William Contreras and a sac fly from Jake Bauers.

Then in the 3rd, Mitchell dropped in a one out double just barely fair down the left field line. Controversy later struck in that inning when Mitchell was running home on a safety squeeze bunt from Cooper Pratt. Spencer Steer glove flipped the ball to Tyler Stephenson and Mitchell was ruled out at the plate. After a lengthy review in which multiple replay angles seemed to show Mitchell beat the tag, the call somehow stood and he was ruled out. But was Mitchell out?

“No. Absolutely not.” Mitchell said.

“Our guy that does video, he’s the best there is and [Mitchell]’s safe in his mind and he has a picture of him being safe….There is a picture of him touching the plate. We can see it from the angle we have, and I’m sure they have that angle.” Pat Murphy said.

The game remained tied at 2-2 and it stayed that way until the 7th inning. Andrew Vaughn ripped a two-out double to center past the diving Matt McLain to start the rally. Garrett Mitchell, after just missing a home run in the 5th inning and having to settle for another double, then ripped a triple off the angled wall out in center, his fourth hit of the night. It scored Vaughn to give the Crew the lead. Mitchell then scored a few pitches later on a wild pitch and this time there was no controversy at the plate.

Mitchell finished the night 4-for-4 at the plate, just inches away from a cycle. He raised his batting average on the season to .264 after coming into the night hitting .251. Mitchell’s OPS now sits exactly at .800.

“Take any other player in baseball that’s been missing for four years, to have him play this way particularly tonight. The four at-bats, the baserunning, the whole thing, I mean, I didn’t think it could happen. I didn’t expect anything close to this for this kid. I’m really happy for him. He’s just played every day, done whatever, hitting against lefties tonight, that’s something that he’s just gotten better and better. I commend his teammates for welcoming him back and seeking to understand what he’s been through, watching us play for four years. So it’s a great story” Murphy said.

Shane Drohan had another strong performance out of the rotation, even though he was pitching against the Reds in back-to-back outings.

“We worked on some stuff in the bullpen a couple days after the start in Cincinnati. Really just feeling out the direct line we wanted for the slider, it felt like in Cincinnati that was where I came up short, just not throwing good sliders late in counts. So we worked on that in the bullpen the other day and threw it well tonight, but I think it still goes back to that fastball.” Drohan said.

Drohan exited after 5.2 IP, allowing six hits and two runs while striking out seven. Coming on in relief of Drohan was Aaron “The Vulture” Ashby. Ashby pitched in parts of three scoreless innings and was the pitcher of record when Mitchell gave the Brewers the lead in the 7th.

As a result, Ashby was able to earn his major league-leading 12th win of the season and improve to 12-1. Abner Uribe, who was feeling under the weather and a little dehydrated, was able to lock down the 8th after the Brewers were unsure if he’d be available tonight. Then Trevor Megill closed things down in the 9th.

The Brewers have a chance to completely sweep the Reds in this four game series on Thursday afternoon and they’ll have their ace on the bump in Jacob Misiorowski.