Vikings Want 2027 First-Round Pick From Giants For J.J. McCarthy (Report)

J.J. McCarthy was once viewed as the future of the Minnesota Vikings. The former first-round pick is now sitting behind Kyler Murray and Carson Wentz, leaving his place with the team uncertain.

That uncertainty has opened the door to a possible trade. The New York Giants lost Jaxson Dart for the rest of the regular season, and league sources say the team is considering its quarterback options. McCarthy is reportedly among the names being discussed.

Vikings Reportedly Want a First-Round Pick for J.J. McCarthy

The Vikings are asking the Giants for a 2027 first-round pick for J.J. McCarthy, according to a report circulating Sunday. New York and Minnesota are reportedly still discussing a possible deal as the Giants search for another quarterback.

WOAH.

The #Vikings are asking for a 2027 FIRST round pick when the #Giants inquired about the availability of QB JJ McCarthy.

Minnesota knows the situation New York is in, as they had to trade a first and fourth round pick to the #Eagles back in 2016 after Teddy… pic.twitter.com/MbM0s121Cr

— NFC North News (@NFCNorthNewss) September 26, 2026

The price would be a big investment for a quarterback with only 10 NFL starts. McCarthy completed 57.6% of his passes last season for 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. He also won six of his 10 starts.

Minnesota has reasons to think carefully before moving him. McCarthy is only 23 years old and remains on his rookie contract. The Vikings kept him through the offseason despite trade speculation, showing they still valued the former No. 10 overall pick.

Tom Pelissero recently identified McCarthy as an intriguing option for New York. The Giants extensively scouted him before the 2024 draft, and his ability to move outside the pocket could fit parts of the offense built around Dart.

Jaxson Dart’s Injury Changed the Giants’ Plans

Dart suffered a serious left knee injury during New York’s loss to the Los Angeles Rams. The Giants later confirmed that he would miss the rest of the regular season, leaving Jameis Winston to take over at quarterback.

The timing has forced New York to consider options outside its current quarterback room. Pelissero reported that general manager Joe Schoen has been working the phones and that the Giants could add another passer as soon as Monday.

McCarthy could give New York another young quarterback while providing insurance for the future. The Giants still believe in Dart, but his injury created an immediate need for more help at the position.

The biggest issue is Minnesota’s reported asking price. A 2027 first-round pick would be a major investment in a quarterback with limited NFL experience.

However, the Vikings could have a difficult time accepting less for a 23-year-old former top-10 pick. Minnesota previously chose to continue developing McCarthy rather than trade him during the offseason.

The Giants need another quarterback, while the Vikings reportedly want a first-round pick in return. The outcome of those talks could decide whether J.J. McCarthy’s time in Minnesota ends before he receives another chance to establish himself.

More NFL News:

• Caleb Williams Sidelined, Bears’ QB Mystery Won’t Be Solved Until Monday Night

• NFL’s Hypocrisy Exposed As Players Are Fined For Mock Drinking While League Profits From Beer Sponsors

• Saquon Barkley And DeVonta Smith Cleared, But Eagles Lose Key Weapon Before Bears Game

• “One Of The Worst Trades Ever”: Sauce Gardner Hasn’t Won A Game In The U.S. In 644 Days Since Colts Trade

• “We Gotta Keep This Quarterback”: Chiefs Star Opens His Wallet To Save Mississippi State QB From Transfer

The post Vikings Want 2027 First-Round Pick From Giants For J.J. McCarthy (Report) appeared first on Gridiron Heroics.