Blue Jays Draft Recap: Day 2

Toronto Blue Jays

The second 80% of the 2026 MLB amateur draft occurred yesterday afternoon. The Blue Jays made 16 additional picks following the three they had yesterday.

The theme today was cutting deals. The Jays will likely need to come up with extra money to pay Cole Carlon and Will Brick, both of whom were generally expected to be taken higher than they were and might be able to command over slot bonuses. Brick in particular has the leverage of honouring his commitment to Mississippi State and potentially going in the first round three years from now.

As a consequence, Toronto spent rounds 5-10 picking up college players, mostly seniors who lack the leverage of going back to school. They’ll sign for less than their slot values, freeing up the money the Jays need. It’s worth noting that while these players are lesser known, that doesn’t mean that they aren’t talented. You only need to look at Danny Thompson jr., who signed as a fifth year super senior for just $5,000 last year and has already forced is way up to AA with excellent results in his first full pro season, to see how some of these guys might pop.

The other theme is contact. They selected several elite contact hitters. Of course, being later in the draft, getting elite contact came with questions about defensive homes and typically little to no power, but the Blue Jays clearly value pure hitting ability very highly and have for years. When shopping the scratch and dent section of the draft, it makes sense that they’d be willing to accept some other limitations to get their favourite tool.

• 5th Round: Nolan Higgins, RHP, Michigan State The big (6’4″, 215lbs) right hander struggled through his first three seasons in East Lansing, but a move to the bullpen produced a hump in results this season. His 5.20 ERA isn’t shiny, but he struck out 62 batters in 45 innings against just 13 walks. His fastball is 93-95, occasionally reaching as high as 98. He pairs it with a quality low-80s curve that he can land in the zone for called strikes, and a two-plane slider with plus spin rates. Lack of a change-up and a history of command issues in the rotation suggest he’s a pure reliever, but he has the stuff to work in that role.

• 6th Round: Gable Mitchell, SS, Iowa Mitchell has been a three year starter at Iowa. He’s walked more than he struck out in his college career, and did the same with wood bats during two summers in the Northwoods League. He doesn’t have a ton of over the fence power (just 5 home runs this past season), but he did hit 15 doubles and 5 triples this last season. Gable is an above average runner and solid defender who profiles as an OBP-based utility infielder.

• 7th Round: Dean West, OF, UCLA Baseball America’s prospect in the draft, West is a plus contact switch hitter who struck out just over 10% of the time in college and in the Cape Cod League, the top wood bat college summer league. At 5’9″ and 185lbs, he’s not a power hitter, although he did manage seven home runs this past season, but he’s an above average runner who might work in centre field, can steal a base (27 for 32 in college), and could be an OBP-first table setter type.

• 8th Round: Jake Bennett, C, Dallas Baptist Played two years at the powerhouse San Jacinto Junior College before transferring to Dallas Baptist. Hit 31 home runs in 309 PA after transferring, and has the easy plus raw power to back that up. Bennett’s approach is patient, sometimes crossing over into passive, which lead to a 15% walk rate but a high-ish for a lower conference 20% strikeout rate. He’s notionally a catcher but spent more time at DH in college, and probably plays there and at first as a pro.

• 9th Round: Joey Urban, OF, U Southern Mississippi Urban had something of a breakout senior year at Souther Miss this season, cutting his strikeout rate from 20% to under 14% while increasing his walks and launching 15 home runs and 29 total extra base hits. He played all over the diamond as well.

• 10th Round: Bryce Chance, OF, Mississippi State A three year starter at State, Chance almost never misses pitches inside the zone (95% zone contact this past season). That’s very impressive given the quality of SEC pitching. He also has an approach, having walked more than he struck out in college. That approach comes with almost no over the fence power (14 home runs in nearly 900 college PAs), but he produces his share of doubles. Chance plays all three outfield positions and profiles as a contact oriented utility guy.

• 11th Round: Brayden Martin, 3B, Maryland The most extreme in a draft full of contact profiles. Martin almost never swings (30% this past season) and never misses when he does (a nearly unheard of 96% overall contact rate, 98% inside the zone). On the plus side, that means that with both metal and wood bats he strikes out less than 10% of the time and walks nearly twice that often. On the minus, he’s got just 5 home runs and 30 total extra base hits in 806 college PA and has never hit a homer with a wood bat in almost 400 PA. He’s a 70-grade runner who’s an effective base stealer, but a weak arm might push him to left field as a pro.

• 12th Round: Santi Garcia, LHP, LSU Garcia began in community college before transferring up to Oregon, and then across to LSU as a junior. In his NCAA seasons, he struck out nearly a third of the batters he faced but also walked almost 20%.

• 13th Round: Mathis Nayral, RHP, Kansas Nayral hails from Toulouse, France, and spent a couple of seasons at Cochise College in Douglas, AZ, before transferring to Kansas this season. He struck out 71 against 28 walks in 18 appearances (17 starts) and 69.0 innings.

• 14th Round: Connor Kelley, RHP, UT San Antonio Split his time between the rotation and bullpen this season, striking out 73 against 22 walks in 66.1 innings.

• 15th Round: Oliver de la Torre, RHP, Cal Berkeley Transitioned from a swing man role to the rotation this season, posting a 3.76 ERA while striking out 72 against 23 walks in 81.1 innings.

• 16th Round: Carson Cormier, RHP Illinois State Played at TCU last season but failed to get much playing time, so he transferred down to Illinois State. Worked mostly in the rotation, striking out 74 against just 12 walks in 69.0 innings.

• 17th Round: Landon Waters, RHP, Ole Miss working as a one inning reliever, struck out 25 against 12 walks over 24.0 innings in 2026. Also had a strong showing in the 2026 Northwoods League, with 25 punch outs on just 70 batters faced and only six walks.

• 18th Round: Jake McCoy, LHP, South Carolina McCoy struggled to the tune of a 7.11 ERA during two seasons at USC, but had a huge breakout in the Cape Cod League last summer. He struck out 25 of 54 batters faced, allowing just three walks and 13 hits over 12.1 innings. Scouts viewed him as the best pitcher in the league that summer. McCoy is a little undersized at 6’1″ and 185lbs. His fastball sits 93-94 and touches 98, with plus ride up in the zone that’s complemented by a low release point He pairs the fastball with a plus sweeper and a rarely used but potentially average change up. He blew out his elbow before the 2026 season, but at least per Baseball America was viewed as a potential top 5 round pick anyway. That he’s still on the board in the 18th round suggests he’ll be expensive to sign, and he likely represents an insurance plan in case the Jays are able to sign a higher pick for significantly less than expected due to medical or other issues.

• 19th Round: Cole Travers, SS, St. Jon Neumann HS, Florida Perfect Game’s number 32 high school third base prospect, committed to Stetson University. Per PG’s grading system, a potential top 10 round draft pick. As with McCoy, unlikely to sign unless the Jays wind up with an unexpected amount of extra bonus money.

• 20th Round: Eddie Rosado, OF, Holy Ghost Prep School, Pennsylvania Perfect Game’s number 75 high school outfield prospect, committed to St. Joseph’s University. Per PG’s grading system, was regarded as a high end college prospect with some potential to be drafted. Again, I would guess unlikely to sign.

5th Round: Nolan Higgins, RHP, Michigan State The big (6’4″, 215lbs) right hander struggled through his first three seasons in East Lansing, but a move to the bullpen produced a hump in results this season. His 5.20 ERA isn’t shiny, but he struck out 62 batters in 45 innings against just 13 walks. His fastball is 93-95, occasionally reaching as high as 98. He pairs it with a quality low-80s curve that he can land in the zone for called strikes, and a two-plane slider with plus spin rates. Lack of a change-up and a history of command issues in the rotation suggest he’s a pure reliever, but he has the stuff to work in that role.

6th Round: Gable Mitchell, SS, Iowa Mitchell has been a three year starter at Iowa. He’s walked more than he struck out in his college career, and did the same with wood bats during two summers in the Northwoods League. He doesn’t have a ton of over the fence power (just 5 home runs this past season), but he did hit 15 doubles and 5 triples this last season. Gable is an above average runner and solid defender who profiles as an OBP-based utility infielder.

7th Round: Dean West, OF, UCLA Baseball America’s prospect in the draft, West is a plus contact switch hitter who struck out just over 10% of the time in college and in the Cape Cod League, the top wood bat college summer league. At 5’9″ and 185lbs, he’s not a power hitter, although he did manage seven home runs this past season, but he’s an above average runner who might work in centre field, can steal a base (27 for 32 in college), and could be an OBP-first table setter type.

8th Round: Jake Bennett, C, Dallas Baptist Played two years at the powerhouse San Jacinto Junior College before transferring to Dallas Baptist. Hit 31 home runs in 309 PA after transferring, and has the easy plus raw power to back that up. Bennett’s approach is patient, sometimes crossing over into passive, which lead to a 15% walk rate but a high-ish for a lower conference 20% strikeout rate. He’s notionally a catcher but spent more time at DH in college, and probably plays there and at first as a pro.

9th Round: Joey Urban, OF, U Southern Mississippi Urban had something of a breakout senior year at Souther Miss this season, cutting his strikeout rate from 20% to under 14% while increasing his walks and launching 15 home runs and 29 total extra base hits. He played all over the diamond as well.

10th Round: Bryce Chance, OF, Mississippi State A three year starter at State, Chance almost never misses pitches inside the zone (95% zone contact this past season). That’s very impressive given the quality of SEC pitching. He also has an approach, having walked more than he struck out in college. That approach comes with almost no over the fence power (14 home runs in nearly 900 college PAs), but he produces his share of doubles. Chance plays all three outfield positions and profiles as a contact oriented utility guy.

11th Round: Brayden Martin, 3B, Maryland The most extreme in a draft full of contact profiles. Martin almost never swings (30% this past season) and never misses when he does (a nearly unheard of 96% overall contact rate, 98% inside the zone). On the plus side, that means that with both metal and wood bats he strikes out less than 10% of the time and walks nearly twice that often. On the minus, he’s got just 5 home runs and 30 total extra base hits in 806 college PA and has never hit a homer with a wood bat in almost 400 PA. He’s a 70-grade runner who’s an effective base stealer, but a weak arm might push him to left field as a pro.

12th Round: Santi Garcia, LHP, LSU Garcia began in community college before transferring up to Oregon, and then across to LSU as a junior. In his NCAA seasons, he struck out nearly a third of the batters he faced but also walked almost 20%.

13th Round: Mathis Nayral, RHP, Kansas Nayral hails from Toulouse, France, and spent a couple of seasons at Cochise College in Douglas, AZ, before transferring to Kansas this season. He struck out 71 against 28 walks in 18 appearances (17 starts) and 69.0 innings.

14th Round: Connor Kelley, RHP, UT San Antonio Split his time between the rotation and bullpen this season, striking out 73 against 22 walks in 66.1 innings.

15th Round: Oliver de la Torre, RHP, Cal Berkeley Transitioned from a swing man role to the rotation this season, posting a 3.76 ERA while striking out 72 against 23 walks in 81.1 innings.

16th Round: Carson Cormier, RHP Illinois State Played at TCU last season but failed to get much playing time, so he transferred down to Illinois State. Worked mostly in the rotation, striking out 74 against just 12 walks in 69.0 innings.

17th Round: Landon Waters, RHP, Ole Miss working as a one inning reliever, struck out 25 against 12 walks over 24.0 innings in 2026. Also had a strong showing in the 2026 Northwoods League, with 25 punch outs on just 70 batters faced and only six walks.

18th Round: Jake McCoy, LHP, South Carolina McCoy struggled to the tune of a 7.11 ERA during two seasons at USC, but had a huge breakout in the Cape Cod League last summer. He struck out 25 of 54 batters faced, allowing just three walks and 13 hits over 12.1 innings. Scouts viewed him as the best pitcher in the league that summer. McCoy is a little undersized at 6’1″ and 185lbs. His fastball sits 93-94 and touches 98, with plus ride up in the zone that’s complemented by a low release point He pairs the fastball with a plus sweeper and a rarely used but potentially average change up. He blew out his elbow before the 2026 season, but at least per Baseball America was viewed as a potential top 5 round pick anyway. That he’s still on the board in the 18th round suggests he’ll be expensive to sign, and he likely represents an insurance plan in case the Jays are able to sign a higher pick for significantly less than expected due to medical or other issues.

19th Round: Cole Travers, SS, St. Jon Neumann HS, Florida Perfect Game’s number 32 high school third base prospect, committed to Stetson University. Per PG’s grading system, a potential top 10 round draft pick. As with McCoy, unlikely to sign unless the Jays wind up with an unexpected amount of extra bonus money.

20th Round: Eddie Rosado, OF, Holy Ghost Prep School, Pennsylvania Perfect Game’s number 75 high school outfield prospect, committed to St. Joseph’s University. Per PG’s grading system, was regarded as a high end college prospect with some potential to be drafted. Again, I would guess unlikely to sign.