Opinion: Conor McGregor’s return exposes the UFC’s biggest failure

Conor McGregor’s long-awaited return highlights a lingering
problem for the promotion. | 📷: Getty/UFC

Editor’s note: The views and opinions expressed below are those
of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of
Sherdog.com, its affiliates and sponsors or its parent company,
Evolve Media.

* * *
This weekend marks the return of Conor
McGregor to mixed martial arts from a five-year absence. While

UFC 329 has proven to produce more buzz than the usual numbered
event, it has been muted some as McGregor’s star has faded from its
peak.

That isn’t a surprise, but the amount it has dimmed appears to be a
bit more than the
Ultimate Fighting Championship anticipated. There are some
outside confluences that could be playing a part — the focus of
the USA’s 250th birthday this past weekend and the surprise success
of the USA’s soccer team in the World Cup — but given McGregor
used to be a force unto himself. That no longer appears to be the
case.

That isn’t to say McGregor doesn’t pull a lot of weight in this
late stage of his career. His run up to claiming the champ-champ
label was unprecedented. It wasn’t just what he did in the cage. It
was that he predicted it beforehand. He carried himself with a
swagger that hadn’t ever been displayed and has only been poorly
imitated since. Even if his personality was a turn-off for MMA
fans, there was no denying that his cheeky comments were the peak
of amusement. Phrases such as “red panty night” entered the
lexicon. For some of us, we didn’t fully recognize just how special
the entirety of his run was until it was long gone.

Why Conor McGregor still overshadows Max Holloway and the UFC’s
current roster

Since claiming the second title, McGregor has done more to
embarrass himself than ingratiate himself to the MMA world. He’s
fortunate the fumes of his magical run have managed to carry over
for the last decade. In four contests, he’s managed to win just one
of those fights and dominated the headlines more with his legal
battles than his accomplishments in the sport. Throw in the debates
of whether he has abused steroids and the controversy of his broken
toe that forced him out of his contest with Michael
Chandler and it’s hard to find much positive that has befallen
McGregor since that time.

Despite all that, it could be argued McGregor is still the biggest
star the UFC has. Despite his run being what it was — and I’ve
already emphasized how great it was — that shouldn’t be the case a
decade after. There have been plenty who’ve accomplished major
achievements in that time — including McGregor’s opponent this
weekend, Max
Holloway — but the UFC has been unable to turn that into the
type of capital to make them a star. The major question is whether
that has been a deliberate maneuver on their part.

While the UFC benefitted from McGregor’s rise, they also didn’t
like their brand being the B-side to McGregor’s popularity. He
became too big for the UFC to control, resulting in his excursion
into boxing with Floyd
Mayweather Jr. Following McGregor’s massive payday from that
gig, there proved to be a confluence of UFC fighters expressing an
interest in boxing gigs, hoping to receive the greater payouts the
sister sport of MMA provides. Having their employees seek out a
sport they are inferior at to receive a boost into their bank
account isn’t a good look for the UFC. All because one fighter
became bigger than the organization.

It’s worth keeping in mind the UFC let Francis
Ngannou walk when he expressed interest in partaking in boxing
contests despite being the reigning UFC heavyweight champion. I’m
not saying Ngannou’s popularity was anywhere near McGregor’s — nor
would it exceed it — but Ngannou’s ability to put his opponents to
sleep made him an easy to promote fighter. And yet, rather than pay
Ngannou what he wanted and/or allow him to participate in boxing
matches that would likely raise his profile — and likely make him
more valuable to the UFC — it was worth cutting him loose for the
UFC brass.

The way they’ve handled Holloway is further indicative of some
reluctance to boost him. Holloway is the owner of two of the most
inimitable moments in combat sports history, much less the UFC.
When Holloway was facing Calvin
Kattar, he looked over at the broadcast booth and declared
himself the best boxer in the UFC as he managed to slip five
punches from Kattar. In that contest, Holloway landed a UFC record
445 significant strikes. The numbers and the footage was there for
the UFC to brag on. To make a star out of. And while I understand
they didn’t ignore his performance, they are the professional
promoters. Holloway did his part and provided the ingredients to
make him a star.

Even further, do I really need to mention the epic knockout of
Justin
Gaethje at UFC
300? In the final seconds of the fifth round, despite being
well on his way to a decision victory, Holloway pointed to the mat
and encouraged Gaethje to slug it out in the closing seconds,
giving Gaethje a chance to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat.
Instead, Holloway delivered one of the most brutal one-punch KOs on
a fighter whose chin had been granite up to that point. Yet,
despite overshadowing McGregor in accomplishment over the last
decade, Holloway’s popularity is firmly behind McGregor.

I understand in reality that it’s ridiculous to compare McGregor’s
popularity with anyone; he transcended the sport. But if the UFC is
the preeminent MMA promotion in the world, they should be able to
get someone with the likeable personality of Holloway in
combination with his accomplishments and make them a name that
would be recognized outside of MMA circles, right? It would appear
I set my expectations too high…

Why the UFC still hasn’t produced another crossover superstar
after Conor McGregor

The UFC knows how to promote itself and that’s about it. They do
just enough to be able to proclaim lip service, but they have a
hard limit on what they will do for the fighters as individuals.
When was the last time they had a promotion for a pay-per-view
along the lines of what they did when McGregor and Jose Aldo for
UFC
189? The ones where they were walking through Vegas and
McGregor takes off his sunglasses? I remember those promotions very
well, better than any promotions since that point. Despite having
far more revenue now than they did at that time over a decade ago,
there hasn’t anything remotely close to what they did to promote
that fight in the way they did. Well… perhaps the return of
Ronda
Rousey in late 2016, but that was a decade ago as well for
someone else who had transcended the sport. Given the UFC refuses
to allow anyone to become larger than the promotion anymore, it’s
no surprise it has been unable to create stars, even when the
ingredients are there for it.