NFL survivor contest picks, predictions, advice, strategy: My favorite Week 1 selections
You’ve got a better chance of stepping up into the hole against Derrick Henry than you do of stopping the momentum of NFL Survivor contests in the current football betting landscape.
The world’s largest (legal) contest, hosted at Circa Sports in Las Vegas has over 20,000 entries for its guaranteed $20 million pool, and it’s not even the biggest prize available in the space for this coming season.
The siren’s song of “just” needing to pick one winner per week in America’s most dissected sport makes everyone believe they can navigate the perils and potholes that the unpredictability of football supplies, but there’s more to it than just “pick and pray.”
Upgrade to Fantasy Plus and gain your edge in player projections and much more
Of course, you don’t need to play in a high-roller edition of survivor. You, your friends, and family, can play along as well here at Yahoo Sports, but a smaller pool of participants also changes the calculus when it comes to strategy. After all, the fewer the entrants, the less conceptual risk is necessary.
Each week (until we’ve exhausted all reasonable paths of survival), we’ll look at the Survivor Contest landscape, and the best options available, while understanding that it matters who you’ve already taken, and what you might be giving up by burning a team that week.
Week 1 moneylines
How likely is a team to win and you’ll advance? The betting market provides the answer to that each week with the moneyline, which we can convert to an implied win probability.
Market power ratings
It’s not as simple as picking the team most likely to win, because once you use that team, you can’t use them again. What is simple is that if you’re going to make it through the 18-week season, then you need to use 18 teams. That means, at some point, you’ll be trusting the 18th-best team in the NFL — an unnerving thought.
Here’s a list of the current top 18 teams (with help from the betting market), and an estimation of their value to the point spread:
-
Rams: 19.7
-
Seahawks: 18.1
-
Bills: 17.8
-
Ravens: 17.3
-
Lions: 16.7
-
Chargers: 16.7
-
Chiefs: 16.5
-
Packers: 16.5
-
49ers: 16.5
-
Texans: 16.5
-
Eagles: 16.2
-
Patriots: 16.2
-
Bears: 15.9
-
Cowboys: 15.7
-
Broncos: 15.7
-
Bengals: 15.7
-
Jaguars: 14.6
-
Vikings: 14.0
Picking the most likely team to win each week, or the highest available team on this list above, means that you’re giving up the opportunity to use them again later, and while every week is technically created equal, trusting a team in September is nerve-wracking, but doing so at some point in December is real tension.
Week 1’s top choices
As we look at the best options for Week 1 and onward, we’ll be factoring in the decision tree that will sprout from that pick. The implied probability derived from the moneyline should answer any questions about why the favorite should win, but the nuance is found in what you’re giving up by using them now and not later (with a projected point spread projection for those matchups).
Jaguars (78.6%) over Browns
Jacksonville’s not the biggest favorite in Week 1, but you’re backing a team that won nine straight games to end the regular season a year ago.
On the other side, the Browns have tabbed Deshaun Watson as their starting quarterback, but there’s nothing we’ve seen from him in Cleveland — either before he tore his Achilles in 2024 or during this preseason — that would make us think that Cleveland’s offense is going to come alive. Plus, with defensive metrics that went from great to terrible depending on if Myles Garrett was on the field, with the 2025 Defensive Player of the Year in Los Angeles, there’s less to worry about for Trevor Lawrence.
Estimated Availability: 100%
What you’re giving up (projected point spread):
-
Week 10 at Titans (JAX -4.5)
-
Week 12 vs. Titans (JAX -7.5)
It can be a fool’s errand to try to project who the easiest matchups will be down the road, when we haven’t seen anyone play in the regular season, but the Jaguars do have a pair of games with the Titans — a team that’s seen money come against them in Week 1 at home … against the New York Jets.
Chargers (80.9%) over Cardinals
For the second spot on this list — generally reserved for a significant favorite — the game with the biggest line (and likely to be the most popular pick) does come with some trepidation.
Cardinals QB Jacoby Brissett looked more capable last season than, say, Watson has. With legitimate weapons like Trey McBride, Marvin Harrison Jr., the emergent Michael Wilson and a pair of new running backs. Combine that with some uncertainty around the Chargers breaking in a new defensive coordinator — and a new offensive coordinator — and you could envision more of a sweat than you thought you were bargaining for.
Estimated Availability: 100%
What you’re giving up (projected point spread):
-
Week 2 vs. Raiders (LAC -8.5)
-
Week 11 vs. Jets (LAC -8)
-
Week 16 at Dolphins (LAC -7.5)
The other reason(s) not to just roll with the chalk, is that there are three other spots where the Chargers look appealing, and one is literally next week.
At the moment, based on lookahead lines, there are two games with bigger betting lines in Week 2, and two nice options for later in the season might be enough for you to save the Chargers.
Steelers (62.5%) over Falcons
That the Steelers aren’t even considered our “dark horse” pick, only tells you how weird things might get for those either brave enough, or who are in a super-deep pool — where it’s a necessity to zig while others zag.
From a matchup perspective, if you’re ever going to back a 42-year-old quarterback, doing so when the weather is warm is the time to do it.
Aaron Rodgers’ availability isn’t the only consideration on the Pittsburgh side of things. For how long the defending AFC North champions will have a fully healthy defense is anyone’s guess. Specifically, T.J. Watt, who the Steelers have a considerably better record with than without, but also 37-year-old Cameron Hayward and a secondary featuring 31-year-old Jalen Ramsey and 29-year-old Jamel Dean (both older by defensive back standards).
On the Falcons’ side, Tua Tagovailoa will start Week 1, having done very little in the lead-up to the season to take the starting job from Michael Penix Jr., even as Penix Jr. recovers from ACL surgery.
Rodgers is vulnerable against a formidable pass rush, but the Falcons are without both of 2025’s highly-drafted edge rushers: Jalon Walker (season-ending injury) and James Pearce (eight-game suspension).
Estimated Availability: 100%
What you’re giving up (projected point spread):
-
Week 8 vs. Browns (PIT -3)
-
Week 17 at Titans (PIT -1.5)
Before you think we’re irrationally high on the Steelers this season, the fact that the other two weeks where we might consider them come with spread projections shorter than this game with the Falcons should confirm that it might be now or never for Pittsburgh.
You’ll note that the Steelers didn’t make our top-18 list above, but:
-
Pittsburgh just missed the cut, as they’re bunched with the Buccaneers, and Commanders around the top 20
-
So, if you’re in a contest that requires more than 18 teams selected to get to the end (like, Circa’s), then the Steelers become more viable
-
Once you get to the top 16-24 teams in power-ranking, the order becomes personal preference
The dark horse: Raiders (61.9%) over Dolphins
There’s no darker horse than the Raiders, but if you’re looking for a pick with a low selection percentage, you could do worse than backing a team actively trying to win this season versus one that’s more “wait-and-see.”
Kirk Cousins, healthy, and with his old offensive coach from when they were both with the Vikings, provides more certainty on the offensive side than the Dolphins have with new quarterback, Malik Willis, who doesn’t have the same roster support around him that he had in Green Bay.
While both teams have new regimes, the Raiders are further along in their rebuilding plan. For at least one game, Las Vegas has the ideal combination of already having its potential quarterback of the future, without dealing with the growing pains of starting Fernando Mendoza just yet.
Estimated Availability: 100%
What you’re giving up (projected point spread):
-
Week 16 vs. Titans (LV -1)
I think you already knew there wasn’t going to be another glaring spot to take the Raiders, but at least they might be favored at home against the Titans in Week 16?
That’s not something you’d want to plan for, though, as the Raiders aren’t in anyone’s top-18, 20, or even 25 teams, by power rating, and will likely have turned the team over to Mendoza by then.
So, maybe, if there’s 20,000 other entries in your pool, finding yourself in a virtual “Black Hole,” might be the way to play Week 1.
You can find more valuable betting analysis from Yahoo Sports betting contributor, Matt Russell, at THE WINDOW.
Discover more from NAIRAVOICE.COM.NG
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.